Stehly's Bakery and Eatery is known for its homemade food, including fresh roast beef, corn beef, and turkey, as well as a variety of baked goods. It offers a friendly atmosphere with weekly live music entertainment and karaoke nights, making it a lively spot for locals. The establishment also provides catering services for family events.
Customers generally praise the amazing food, especially the large, well-priced sandwiches and the homemade quality of ingredients. The atmosphere, particularly during karaoke nights, is often highlighted for its positive energy and friendly staff. However, there are mixed reviews regarding some baked goods, with specific vegan options sometimes described as excessively sweet, bland, or having texture issues like greasiness or chunks of baking soda. Prices for individual cake slices have also been noted as somewhat high.
Additional Details
The eatery offers catering services for various family events and features live music entertainment on a weekly basis, including popular karaoke nights.
Thursdays are ideal for those who enjoy karaoke night. The restaurant is open Tuesday through Thursday from 8:00 am to 3:00 pm, making it suitable for breakfast and lunch visits during these weekdays.
3
While we were at vegout in Bethlehem, we grabbed a box of vegan apricot Kiffles and a vegan gluten free Tandy cake.
The Kiffles were **excessively** sweet. (And they don’t disclose the ingredients of the “vegan ice cream” bizarre)
The Tandy cake needs to be kept refrigerated because the chocolate isn’t tempered and will soften at room temp. The cake is exactly as I remember Tandy cakes to have been. Spot on dense. but the almond butter is way too bland. It needs peanut butter.
Bought a piece of chocolate cake with peanut butter icing. The flavor of the icing was good. However it had a thick consistency. The cake, was a consistency was average. Not moist, but not drive. The biggest disappointment is when we found several chunks of baking soda in the baked product. Not sure how that’s even possible. Can only think that the soda was rock hard when it was added to the batter. Lastly the $7.50 price tag was a bit much. Had this would have tasted better $5 would have been more in line.
The food is amazing! The sandwiches are huge and the price for them are good. I go up there mostly on Thursdays when it is karakoe night and no matter how bad you might be at singing everyone still encourage you to jeep singing. They bring such a positive energy. I love going there!
I visited Palmer Mall's Mom and Pop's General store and was excited to see vegan carrot cake made by this bakery. I purchased a piece, which was $7.50. Not a bad price for the serving size provided. I was disappointed with my first bite. The frosting didn't taste good at all and the cake portion was the so greasy you can see it pour out as you cut a piece. It has the amount of oil equated to the amount of milk soaked into a piece of tres leches cake. After eating a few more bites I started getting nauseous. I ended up throwing ithe rest away while I was still at the mall. Now I'm burping what tastes like castor oil. This was an epic disappointment and a disgrace to carrot cake. I would not recommend this cake.
Great food! I had the Prime Rib special. It was a risky work lunch but they put it on a wheat wrap and so made me an offer I couldn't refuse! Honestly I felt great afterwards, it was not greasy at all so no lunch lag :) The tomato basil soup was also fantastic. Looking forward to my next visit!
